Can an employee refuse a performance improvement plan in the UK? An employee can refuse to sign a performance improvement plan (PIP), and can disagree with it, comment on it or raise a grievance about it. What they cannot do is make the underlying performance concern go away by refusing. A PIP is not a contract the employee has to accept: it is the employer’s written record of the gap, the standard expected, the support on offer and the review dates. No UK statute requires a PIP or a signature on one. What the law and the Acas Code of Practice do require is a fair process, so a refusal changes how carefully the employer has to run the next steps, not whether there can be next steps at all. This is general information, not legal advice.

Key takeaways

  • Refusing to sign is not refusing the plan. A signature should record that the plan was discussed and received, not that the employee agrees. If they will not sign, note the refusal and carry on.
  • Fairness is the test, not consent. The Acas Code (2015) applies to poor performance as well as misconduct: tell the employee the problem, let them respond, allow a companion at formal meetings and offer an appeal.
  • A grievance can pause the process, not end it. The Code says a disciplinary process may be temporarily suspended to deal with a grievance, or both handled together where they are related.
  • Refusing to do the work is a different matter. Acas lists refusing to do work as an example of a conduct issue, which has its own investigation and process.
  • The stakes rise on 1 January 2027. Under the Employment Rights Act 2025, most employees in England, Scotland and Wales will be able to claim ordinary unfair dismissal after six months, not two years, and the cap on the compensatory award goes.

What “refusing a PIP” can mean, and what to do

When a manager tells HR that someone has “refused the PIP”, it usually means one of five quite different things. Each needs a different response, and treating them all as defiance is how a fixable capability case turns into a dispute.

What the employee doesWhat it usually meansSensible response
Will not sign the planThey do not accept the assessment, or worry a signature admits faultExplain the signature only confirms receipt. Record “discussed on [date], employee declined to sign”, give them a copy and continue.
Disputes the facts or the standardThe evidence or the bar is not clear enough, or they see it differentlyHear them out. Add their comments to the plan. Check the dated examples and the written standard for the role before you go further.
Says the targets or timeline are unreasonableThe plan may be too tight, too vague or missing supportTest the targets against what a competent person in the role delivers. Adjust if they are not achievable in the time given.
Raises a grievance about the manager or the planThey feel singled out or treated unfairlyDeal with the grievance under your procedure. Pause the PIP or run both together if they are related, as the Acas Code allows.
Will not attend meetings or do the agreed workDisengagement, or a health, workload or relationship issue underneathAsk why, in writing. Check for health or a reasonable adjustment. If it is a refusal of reasonable instructions, it may become a conduct matter, handled separately.

The first two rows are by far the most common, and both are signs the plan was not shared or explained well, not proof of bad faith. The PIP template for UK managers already treats the signature as confirmation that the plan was discussed, not as an admission, and leaves space for the employee’s comments. Use that wording from the start and the first refusal often never happens.

What the Acas Code and the law say

The Code covers performance, not just misconduct. The Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures (in effect from 11 March 2015) says disciplinary situations include misconduct and/or poor performance. Employers with a separate capability procedure can use it, but the Code’s basic principles of fairness should still be followed. Those principles are practical: raise and deal with issues promptly, act consistently, establish the facts, tell the employee the basis of the problem and let them put their case before any decision, allow them to be accompanied at formal meetings, and let them appeal a formal decision. None of them depends on the employee agreeing with the plan.

The Code has teeth on both sides. Its foreword explains that a tribunal can increase an award by up to 25 per cent if an employer unreasonably fails to follow it, and reduce an award by up to 25 per cent if an employee unreasonably fails to follow it. An employee who refuses to engage at all is taking a risk too; an employer who skips steps because “they refused anyway” is taking a bigger one.

Grievances and PIPs can overlap. Paragraph 46 of the Code says that where an employee raises a grievance during a disciplinary process, the process may be temporarily suspended to deal with it, and where the two are related it may be appropriate to deal with both at the same time. A grievance is therefore a reason to slow down and listen, not a veto.

Acas expects support and a reasonable timeline. Acas guidance on problems with an employee’s performance (last updated 23 June 2026) describes a PIP as something employers could consider when informal steps have not worked, setting out specific objectives, a reasonable timeline and any further support or training. Its page on dismissals for capability or conduct (same date) says dismissal should be a last resort, and that an employer needs evidence both of the poor performance and of the steps taken to support improvement. The same guidance gives “refusing to do work” as an example of a conduct issue, which is why the last row of the table is handled differently.

The companion right depends on the meeting. Under section 10 of the Employment Relations Act 1999, workers can bring a companion to a disciplinary hearing, which section 13(4) defines as a hearing that could result in a formal warning or some other action. An informal meeting to agree a plan may not meet that test, but many employers allow a companion anyway, and an anxious employee who is refused one is more likely to refuse everything else.

From 1 January 2027, more people can challenge the outcome. Section 25 of the Employment Rights Act 2025, commenced by S.I. 2026/559, cuts the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal from two years to six months and removes the cap on the compensatory award. Government guidance for employers on unfair dismissal rights (2026) confirms this applies in England, Scotland and Wales, and not in Northern Ireland. Capability remains a potentially fair reason under section 98 of the Employment Rights Act 1996, provided the process is fair.

Getting it wrong is expensive even without a tribunal. Research for Acas by Richard Saundry and Peter Urwin, Estimating the costs of workplace conflict (May 2021), estimated around 1.7 million formal disciplinary cases a year in UK organisations at roughly £1,141 each in management time, and an average of £951 per formal grievance. A refused PIP that turns into both is paying twice.

Why refusals stall in 100 to 1,500-person companies

Large employers have employee-relations specialists who have seen hundreds of refused plans. Start-ups often have one manager and a founder who know everyone. Companies in between get the worst of both:

  • The manager has never run a PIP. A first-time manager hears “I won’t sign this” as a challenge to their authority, and either backs down or escalates too quickly. The manager training programme covers the conversation skills that prevent both.
  • The evidence is thin. The plan cites feelings rather than dated examples, and the last two reviews said “meets expectations”. The employee refuses because, on paper, they have a point. Ratings against a clear rating scale in every cycle are the cheapest protection there is.
  • The plan lives in a Word file. Check-in notes are in a manager’s notebook, the HR partner has a different version, and nobody can say whether the agreed support was delivered.
  • It is the first conversation, not the third. If the gap was never raised in a 1:1, the PIP feels like an ambush. Acas expects informal steps first, and a short 1:1 meeting template with dated notes is how you prove they happened.
  • Different teams, different rules. One department puts people on plans quickly, another never does. An employee who knows that will say so in a grievance, and they will be right. The review bias checker helps spot loaded language before it reaches a plan.

Before writing any plan, check whether this is a skill gap at all. The free team performance diagnostic separates a skill gap from a capacity, burnout or motivation problem. A PIP for someone who is simply overloaded is the plan most likely to be refused, and the hardest to defend.

If you also employ people in Ireland

Irish law takes a similar line. Section 6(4)(a) of the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977 lists the capability, competence or qualifications of the employee as grounds on which a dismissal may be fair. The Code of Practice on Grievance and Disciplinary Procedures (S.I. No. 146 of 2000) rests on natural justice: the details of any complaint are put to the employee, they can respond fully, they can be represented, the decision is fair and impartial, and an internal appeal is available. As in the UK, the employee’s agreement to the plan is not the test; the fairness of the process is. Irish procedures are often written to expect representation from the first formal meeting, so a UK template used unchanged in Dublin can fall short.

Our perspective

When a People leader tells me an employee has refused a PIP, my first question is not about the employee. It is: could you show me, on one screen, every conversation that led to this plan? In most companies of this size the honest answer is no. The 1:1 notes are in a notebook, the last review is in a different system, and the plan was written the night before. A refusal is often the employee noticing the same gap the tribunal would.

So I treat a refusal as a quality check. If the standard is written down, the examples are dated, the support has an owner and the employee has been heard, a refusal to sign changes almost nothing; you note it and carry on. If any of those are missing, the refusal is useful: fix the plan now, while it is still a plan and not a claim. With the qualifying period dropping to six months in Great Britain from January, that habit matters for far more of your workforce than it did.

— Ash Taherian, Product Sales Executive, Revolut People

Where Revolut People fits, and where it doesn’t

I work at Revolut People, so weigh this section accordingly. The Performance plan includes probation monitoring tools and PIP templates alongside goals, scorecards and AI-powered 1:1 summaries. For the problem in this post, the useful part is the record: the review scorecard a PIP is written against, the goals, the 1:1 notes where the gap was first raised and the plan’s checkpoints sit on the same employee profile, so HR and the manager are looking at one version. When someone disputes the facts, you can show the history rather than reconstruct it. The product tour shows how reviews and 1:1s connect, and Revolut People for line managers covers the manager’s side.

The limits are real. Software does not make the hard conversation easier, decide whether a refusal is a conduct issue, or replace your capability policy, your HR adviser or a lawyer. It will not stop a manager writing a vague plan. If your company runs very few PIPs and already has a tidy capability procedure, a well-kept template and a shared folder may be enough. The case for one platform is strongest when plans keep failing because the evidence is scattered.

If a plan is being disputed now, or you want a second view before January, book a 15-minute review. Bring your PIP template and capability policy, with names removed.

Step plan: when an employee says no

  1. Pause, do not escalate. Thank them for being direct, end the meeting calmly and agree a follow-up within a few working days. Nothing is decided in the room.
  2. Find out which “no” it is. Use the table above. Ask in writing what they disagree with: the facts, the standard, the targets, the timeline, the support or the manager.
  3. Check your own file first. Is the standard written down for the role? Are the examples dated? Was the gap raised informally, with notes? Is there a health or adjustment question? Fix gaps before you go further. The capability procedure guide sets out what a fair file contains.
  4. Revise and reissue. Add the employee’s comments, adjust targets or support if they were unreasonable, and change the signature line to “I confirm I have received and discussed this plan”. Offer a companion for the follow-up meeting.
  5. If they still decline to sign, record it and continue. Note the date, that the plan was explained and that a copy was given. Hold the checkpoints as planned and share a short written note after each one.
  6. Handle a grievance properly. Run it under your grievance procedure, ideally with someone other than the PIP manager. Decide, with HR, whether to pause the plan or deal with both together.
  7. Separate conduct from capability. If the employee will not attend or do reasonable work, write to them, check for underlying causes and, if it continues, handle it as a conduct matter under your disciplinary procedure, with its own investigation.

Not sure how your review process would stand up to a disputed plan? The two-minute performance health check scores standards, evidence and consistency across your cycle.

Bottom line

An employee can refuse to sign a PIP, disagree with it and raise a grievance about it. That does not stop a fair capability process, and it should not panic the manager. What protects both sides is the same thing the Acas Code asks for: a clear standard, dated evidence, real support, a chance to respond, a companion at formal meetings and an appeal. Build those in from the first 1:1, and a refusal becomes a comment on the file rather than the start of a claim. With six-month unfair dismissal rights arriving in Great Britain on 1 January 2027, now is a good time to check your template and your managers. For the wider picture of underperformance and its costs, see the hidden drag of underperformance.

FAQ

Does an employee have to sign a performance improvement plan?

No. No UK law requires an employee to sign a PIP. A signature should confirm that the plan was discussed and a copy received, not that the employee agrees with it. If they decline, record the date, that the plan was explained and that they were given a copy, and continue with the checkpoints. Inviting written comments usually does more good than insisting on a signature.

How long should a performance improvement plan last?

There is no statutory length in the UK. Acas asks for a reasonable timeline that gives the person a realistic chance to improve, with support and fixed review points. The People Performance Playbook’s own starting point is a six-week plan with SMART targets, which is a practical guideline rather than a legal rule; complex roles or skill gaps may need longer, and Acas mentions extending the timeline where someone improves but not to the agreed level.

Can an employee bring someone to a PIP meeting?

The statutory right to be accompanied by a colleague or trade union representative applies to disciplinary hearings that could result in a formal warning or other action, under the Employment Relations Act 1999. A purely informal meeting to agree a plan may not qualify, but your own procedure can allow a companion anyway, and the Acas Code says employers should allow employees to be accompanied at any formal meeting. In Ireland, the WRC Code expects the employee to be able to be represented during the procedure.

What should be included in a PIP in the UK?

Acas says a PIP should set out specific objectives, a reasonable timeline and any further support or training the employee needs. In practice that means the gap with dated examples, two to four SMART targets, named support with an owner, fixed review dates, the outcomes if targets are met, partly met or missed, and space for the employee’s comments. The UK PIP template follows that structure.

Sources

About the author: Ash Taherian is a Product Sales Executive at Revolut People, based in Dublin, working with People and Finance leaders on review cycles, calibration and the records behind fair performance decisions.

Disclosure: I work for Revolut People, which sells performance management software, so read the product section with that in mind. This post is general information about UK and Irish practice, not legal or HR advice for your situation; take advice before acting on a specific case.