Read the full guide below: why it matters, how to read your result, a worked example and FAQ ↓
Switching HR systems is a big decision, and it is easy to switch for the wrong reasons or stay too long with a tool that no longer fits. This checker helps you test the decision before you start a vendor search, by looking at how well your current setup supports the work your People team actually does.
How it works: answer a short set of questions about your current HRIS: how you run performance reviews and calibration, how much happens in spreadsheets, how well your tools connect and what your team spends time on. The checker turns your answers into a simple read-out of where your current system holds up and where it creates friction. It is a structured self-assessment, not a vendor score, and it does not use outside statistics. If the result points towards a change, use the performance management software buyer’s guide to build your shortlist.
Got your gap score? Want to walk through what it means for a switch?
15-minute review with Ash Taherian, Product Sales Executive at Revolut People. Bring your score and one question; no preparation needed.
Book a 15-minute reviewTool not loading? Open the tool in a new tab.
How the HRIS switch checker works (30-second walkthrough)
What you enter and what you get back. Figures shown are examples.
The complete guide to deciding whether to switch HR systems
For fast-growing businesses, running people processes in Excel is a “disaster waiting to happen.”
The checker above gives you a structured read-out of where your current HR setup holds up and where it creates friction. This guide covers the rest of the decision: why the choice to switch (or stay) is expensive to get wrong, how to answer the checker so the result means something, how to interpret it, a worked example, the most common mistakes, and how to move from “maybe” to a shortlist. It is written for People leaders and the Finance or Operations leaders who own the HR stack at growing companies.
Why the switch decision matters
An HR system is rarely one tool. In most growing companies it is a core HRIS for records and time off, plus a separate performance tool, plus spreadsheets for calibration, plus documents for goals, plus a survey tool. Each was a sensible choice at the time. Together they produce what McKinsey’s 2024 article “In the spotlight: Performance management that puts people first” describes as common reasons leaders lack confidence in their performance systems: fragmentation, informal “shadow” systems, misalignment and inconsistency.
Switching costs are real, too. Data has to be migrated and cleaned, integrations rebuilt, managers retrained, and a review cycle run on the new system before anyone trusts it. Switch for the wrong reason, such as a single irritating feature or a persuasive sales cycle, and you pay those costs without fixing the underlying problem. Stay too long, and the cost shows up instead in the hours managers spend stitching data together, in reviews written from memory, and in calibration done in a spreadsheet nobody can audit.
The CIPD’s performance management factsheet frames performance management as a connected set of activities: objectives, ongoing feedback, development and review. That framing is a useful test for any HR stack: does your setup let those activities connect, or does each one live in a different place?
Signals that point to a switch, and signals that do not
| Usually a real signal | Usually not enough on its own |
|---|---|
| Calibration and ratings live in spreadsheets outside the HR system, every cycle. | The interface looks dated. |
| Managers re-enter the same data in two or more tools. | One missing feature that a workaround covers well. |
| You cannot see goals, feedback and review history for one person in one place. | A competitor uses a different vendor. |
| Reporting to leadership requires manual exports and merges. | A renewal is due and the price went up slightly. |
| Your review process has outgrown what the tool supports (for example, quarterly cycles or calibration). | A new leader prefers the tool they used before. |
The pattern on the left is structural: the system no longer matches how your People team works. The pattern on the right is preference. Structural problems get worse with headcount; preferences usually do not.
How to use the checker
The checker asks 10 yes/no questions, one per screen, covering eight areas: core HRIS, performance (reviews and calibration), goals, 1:1s and feedback, time off, onboarding, reporting and tool sprawl. Answer “Yes” only if that area is covered in one system today. You can go back to change an answer, or use the Y and N keys. To get a useful result:
- Answer for the last full review cycle, not for a normal week. Review season is when stack problems show.
- Count the shadow systems. If calibration happens in a spreadsheet, the honest answer to “reviews include calibration” in your system is No.
- Ask the people who do the work. A People operations lead and one line manager will know where the friction is better than whoever signed the contract.
- Keep it to yes or no about your setup. The questions never need names or employee details. The only place you enter contact details is the optional “Email me my results” form, and you don’t need it to see your result.
The checker is a self-assessment, not an audit or a vendor score, and it does not use outside statistics to calculate your result.
How to interpret your result
Your gap score is the number of “No” answers × 10, so it runs from 0 to 100 and a higher score means more gaps. The score falls into one of three bands: 0–20 “Well consolidated”, 30–50 “Some gaps” and 60–100 “Fragmented stack”. Below the score, the checker lists the areas where your current tools leave gaps, each with a line on what consolidating that area would look like. You can copy the result or a share link with your answers, so a colleague can see the same result.
Read it in three layers.
- What you answered Yes to. These are things a replacement must do at least as well. Write them down as must-keeps before you look at any vendor.
- The gap areas. Separate gaps caused by the tool from gaps caused by your process. A tool cannot fix a review process with no written standards; it can fix data scattered across four places.
- Overall direction. If the gaps sit in one area, extending your current system (an integration, a dedicated performance module) may be cheaper than a full switch. If they span performance, data and reporting, a consolidation is usually worth costing properly.
A result that points towards change is a prompt to build a business case, not a decision. Put the time cost next to it: the review cost calculator shows how many hours your current cycle takes, which is usually the most persuasive number for Finance.
Worked example: a 250-person company
An illustrative company (invented for this example) runs a core HRIS for records and time off, a separate performance tool for review forms, a shared spreadsheet for calibration, and slide decks for quarterly goals. The People operations lead takes the checker and answers No to four questions: reviews include calibration (it happens in a spreadsheet), goals are linked to reviews, leaders see people data without exports, and two or fewer tools cover everything.
That gives a gap score of 40 (“Some gaps”), with Performance, Goals, Reporting and Tool sprawl listed as gap areas. Core HRIS, time off and onboarding were all Yes, so the friction sits in performance, calibration and reporting. That splits the decision. Records, time off and onboarding are not the problem, so the team lists them as must-keeps. Performance is the problem, so the question becomes whether one platform can run goals, reviews, calibration and reporting together while keeping records at least as good.
The team then sizes the cost: using the calculator, 250 reviews at 3 hours each across two cycles is 1,500 manager hours a year before calibration. With that number and a list of must-keeps, they build a shortlist of three vendors and a test script based on their real cycle, rather than vendor scripts.
Six questions to answer before you decide
Whatever the checker says, a switch decision is stronger when the leadership team can answer these questions in writing. They take about an hour with the right people in the room, and they stop the decision drifting into a feature comparison.
- What problem are we solving, in one sentence? “Calibration lives in spreadsheets and nobody trusts the output” is a problem. “We want a better HR system” is not.
- Who feels the pain most? If it is managers during review season, the evaluation should be led by how managers will use the new system, not by the admin console.
- What would we lose? List the integrations, reports and workflows that work today. Those become non-negotiables.
- What does staying cost? Put hours on the friction: re-keyed data, manual reports, spreadsheet calibration. The cost calculator covers the review part.
- When could we switch without disrupting a cycle? Pick the window between two review cycles and work back from it.
- Who owns the change? A named owner in People and a sponsor in Finance or Operations, with time set aside for migration and training.
When staying is the right answer
A result that shows friction does not always mean switching. Staying is often right when the friction is concentrated in one process you have not yet fixed on paper, when a renewal or contract term makes switching expensive this year, or when your People team does not have capacity for a migration before the next cycle. In those cases, write down the friction points, fix the process side (standards, cycle dates, calibration method), and set a date to re-run the checker. If the same friction appears again after a cycle with a clean process, the case for switching is much stronger, and much easier to make to Finance.
Common mistakes
- Switching to fix a process problem. If managers do not know what “good” looks like, a new tool will collect the same inconsistent ratings faster. Fix standards with the framework in parallel.
- Letting the vendor run the evaluation. Test with your own review template, your own calibration scenario and a sample of your own (anonymised) data.
- Ignoring migration. Ask how historical reviews, goals and records move across, who does the work and how long it takes.
- Underestimating change management. Plan manager training and one supported cycle on the new system before you call it done.
- Comparing prices without the time cost. A cheaper tool that keeps calibration in spreadsheets may cost more in hours than it saves in licences.
From result to shortlist
If the checker points to a change, use the performance management software buyer’s guide to turn your must-keeps and friction points into requirements, and read switching from spreadsheets to performance management software for a migration plan. If you are weighing Revolut People specifically, the pricing estimator shows indicative list pricing and LiveFlow’s switch to Revolut People compares two common options. Ash works for Revolut People, so treat product comparisons as coming from an interested party.
Weighing Revolut People specifically? This short film shows how employee records, organisational structure and the HR dashboard sit together. More short films
Sources: McKinsey, In the spotlight: Performance management that puts people first (2024); CIPD, Performance management factsheet; SHRM, Managing employee performance toolkit.
Put this guide to work
Run the HRIS switch checker above, then talk your result through with Ash on a 15-minute review. No preparation needed: bring your result and one question.
FAQ
Who is the checker for?
People and HR leaders, and Finance or Ops leaders who own the HR stack, at companies weighing whether to replace or extend their current HRIS.
Does it recommend a specific vendor?
No. It assesses your current setup against your own answers. Ash works for Revolut People, so if you discuss the result on a call, treat product suggestions as coming from an interested party.
Is my data stored?
Your answers aren’t stored unless you choose to use the optional “Email me my results” form. Answering the 10 yes/no questions and seeing your gap score saves nothing; the share link simply carries your answers in the link itself. If you submit the form, your email, company (if you add it), answers and score are saved so your results can be sent to you and so Ash can follow up about them. The questions never need names or employee details. See the privacy policy.
What should I do after the check?
If it points to a switch, list your must-haves using the buyer’s guide, or book a 15-minute review to talk it through.
How do I know if I need a new HRIS or just a performance tool?
Look at where the friction sits. If records, time off and documents work well and the pain is in goals, reviews and calibration, you may only need a performance layer or a platform that does both well. If friction is spread across data, reporting and performance, consolidation is worth costing.
How long does switching HR systems take?
It depends on headcount, data quality and how many integrations you have. Plan for data migration, manager training and one supported review cycle on the new system, and ask each vendor for a dated plan based on your setup rather than a typical timeline.
What should we test before choosing a vendor?
Run your real process: your review template, a calibration scenario with sample ratings, the leadership report you produce today and a data export. A vendor that only shows its own script has not proved it fits yours.
Is it a bad idea to switch during review season?
Usually. Most teams migrate between cycles so that the first cycle on the new system starts with clean data and trained managers.
More: People Performance Playbook home · framework · review-cycle checklist · blog.