A vendor-neutral guide for HR and People leaders in the UK and Ireland choosing performance management software, building a business case or writing an RFP. It starts from your review process, not a vendor list, and ends with a downloadable scorecard and a pilot plan. Disclosure: Ash Taherian works at Revolut People, so one product in this space is his employer’s. The criteria below apply to every vendor, including Revolut People.

Named comparisons live on two separate pages: Lattice vs Culture Amp vs 15Five for scale-ups and alternatives to Culture Amp, Leapsome, 15Five and BambooHR. This guide is the method you can use with either.

Quick answer: what to look for

What should performance management software do for a UK scale-up? It should run your review process as it is, not force a new one: goals that link to reviews, self, peer and manager input, calibration that flags uneven ratings, and a written record each employee can see, in line with Acas guidance on documented reviews. For UK and Irish teams, also check access controls, data protection and integration with your HRIS and payroll before you compare prices.

  • Process fit first. Write down your cycle, forms and grades, then check each tool runs them without workarounds.
  • Goals, reviews and calibration in one flow. Goals should feed the review, and calibration should show the evidence behind each grade. See what calibration software should do.
  • A written record employees can see. Acas advises keeping a written record of review discussions and sharing it with the employee.
  • UK and Ireland checks. Access controls, data protection, HRIS and payroll integration, and clear answers on where data is held.
  • Score, then pilot. Use one scorecard for every vendor, then pilot the top two with two job families before you sign.

Start with your process, not the vendor list

Most pages on this topic are vendor product pages or tool lists. They answer “which tools exist?”, not “which tool runs our process?”. Software cannot replace the judgement in calibration or fix a process that is not written down.

If you are not sure the timing is right yet, start with when a company should buy performance management software: the seven triggers, and the cases where a template is still the better choice.

Before you compare tools, write down what you want the tool to run:

  • What you assess: for example deliverables (goals), skills and behaviours linked to your values, each with a scorecard.
  • Your grades and talent bar: the rating scale, what each level means at each seniority, and who can change a grade.
  • Your cycle: how often you review, who gives input (self, peer, manager, upward), and when calibration happens.
  • What the grade drives: promotion, development, improvement plans and pay, and who signs off each.

The method works without software; software makes it easier to run consistently, with the evidence in one place. The performance management framework lays out one way to write this down. If you are moving off spreadsheets, the guide to switching from spreadsheets to performance management software covers the move itself.

For your business case, the performance review cost calculator estimates the manager hours your current cycle takes.

What changes at 200, 500 and 2,000 people

The same criteria apply at every size, but their weight shifts as a company grows. The stages below are illustrations to help you think about fit, not thresholds or data. Your own complexity (countries, entities, layers of management, how grades link to pay) matters more than headcount.

Around 200 people

The People team is usually small, many managers are new to managing, and the process may still live in documents and spreadsheets. The priority is a clear written process that managers actually complete: one review form, simple goals, a rating scale everyone understands and a record each employee can see. Don’t buy for complexity you don’t have yet, but check the tool can grow with you.

Around 500 people

There are now several departments, more layers of management and possibly more than one entity or country. The problem shifts from “do reviews happen?” to “are they consistent across managers?”. Calibration across departments, permissions by role and region, and a reliable sync with your HRIS start to matter more than form design.

Around 2,000 people

Calibration usually runs in layers, by department and by function. IT, security and data protection teams join the evaluation, procurement may want a formal RFP and a security questionnaire, and changes to forms or cycles need some control. At this stage, check how the tool handles multi-stage calibration, single sign-on and provisioning, audit trails for grade changes, and the effort needed to change a cycle without a vendor project.

UK and Ireland checks

Add these checks for UK and Irish teams. None of this is legal advice; involve your employment and data protection advisers.

A documented process consistent with Acas guidance

Acas says employers “should conduct regular performance reviews for anyone with the legal status of employee” and that “it’s a good idea to do them at least once a year”. It also says: “It’s important to keep a written record of what is discussed. This should be shared with the employee afterwards.” (Acas, Performance management: reviews and appraisals, last updated 23 June 2026.) Acas also advises managers to talk to employees about performance informally between formal reviews, through feedback, coaching and regular check-ins.

So check that the tool can: schedule cycles at whatever frequency you choose; record what was discussed and agreed; share that record with the employee; and keep check-ins and feedback alongside formal reviews. Acas says its advice is for workers and employers across England, Scotland and Wales (Acas advice), so teams in Northern Ireland and Ireland should check the local equivalent with their own advisers.

Why it matters in practice: the CIPD Good Work Index 2026 found that 15% of UK workers never meet their line manager to discuss performance, and only 57% agree their manager provides useful feedback on their work (CIPD, as cited in the UK and Ireland performance review benchmarks 2026). In Ireland, 61% of HR respondents to CIPD Ireland’s HR Practices in Ireland 2026 named line managers not having enough time for people management as the biggest constraint on HR’s impact (same source). A tool should make the conversation and the record easy for busy managers.

Access controls and data protection

Performance data is sensitive. UK teams work under UK GDPR and Irish teams under the EU GDPR. Ask every vendor:

  • Who can see ratings, grade history and feedback, and can you limit HR access by country or entity?
  • Can payroll see pay data without seeing performance data, and the other way round?
  • Which single sign-on providers are supported, and is user provisioning (SCIM) available for yours?
  • Can you set data retention periods, and how do you export one employee’s data for a subject access request?
  • Do AI features see only what the user is already allowed to see?

HRIS and payroll integration

Decide which system is the source of truth for employee records, and check each tool has a documented integration with your HRIS and a clear route to payroll (direct, through the HRIS, or by export). Ask which fields sync, in which direction, and what happens when someone leaves. The stack-fit checker helps you map your current HR, payroll and identity tools before you speak to vendors.

Data-location questions to ask

Don’t assume; ask each vendor in writing:

  • Where is our data stored and processed, and where are backups held?
  • Which sub-processors handle our data, and in which countries?
  • What transfer mechanism applies if data leaves the UK or EEA?
  • Which certifications or audit reports can you share, and when were they last renewed?

The scorecard

How do I choose between performance management tools? Score each tool against your own process first: process fit, goals, reviews, calibration, evidence, integrations, security and pricing transparency. Then pilot the top two with two job families for one short cycle before signing.

Use the same eight criteria and the same questions for every vendor. Score what you saw on your own data, not what you were told: 0 (not shown), 1 (partly, or with workarounds) or 2 (shown working).

CriterionWhat good looks likeHow to test it
Process fitRuns your forms, grades and cycle without heavy workaroundsAsk them to configure one of your real review forms and rating scales
GoalsCompany, team and individual goals with owners and progress, linked to the reviewSet up one team’s goals and check they appear in that team’s reviews
ReviewsSelf, peer, manager and upward input; same questions for every managerRun one review end to end for a test employee
CalibrationShows ratings by manager, flags outliers, records changes with a reason and sign-offCalibrate a sample team and check the original and final grades are both kept
EvidenceEach rating backed by goals, examples or feedback; a written record the employee can seeOpen a test employee’s record and see what they would see
IntegrationsDocumented integrations with your HRIS, identity provider and the tools goals live inCheck the vendor’s public docs for your exact systems
SecurityRole and regional permissions, SSO, retention settings, clear data-location answersSend the questions above to the vendor and to your IT lead
Pricing transparencyA written quote for your headcount, with minimums, add-ons and implementation fees statedCompare total first-year and renewal cost, not list price

Download the UK scorecard (PDF) Vendor-neutral. Space for three tools, the UK and Ireland checks and your pilot notes.

On pricing: some vendors publish prices and some quote only, so compare like with like. For named vendors, see the dated figures in performance management software pricing. For Revolut People, the pricing estimator gives an estimate for your headcount; the actual price is a written quote.

Run a two-job-family pilot

The Playbook’s advice is to start with two job families, write their scorecards, run one cycle, then extend. Use the same approach to compare software:

  1. Pick two job families that work differently, for example one with measurable output (such as sales or support) and one where judgement matters more (such as engineering or design).
  2. Write their scorecards and rating scale before any vendor meeting, so every tool is set up the same way.
  3. Put the same people through the top two tools for one short cycle: goals, self and manager reviews, and a calibration session.
  4. Score straight after with the scorecard, and ask managers and employees how long it took and whether the record was clear.
  5. Decide on evidence: configuration effort, clarity of evidence, how calibration went, and the written quote.

Ask each vendor up front how a pilot or proof of concept works with them, what it costs, and what happens to pilot data afterwards. The review-cycle checklist and how to run a calibration meeting help you run the pilot cycle itself.

Types of tools and how to shortlist

Performance tools fall into three broad types. None is better in general; it depends on your process and what you already own.

  • HRIS performance modules. The performance features inside your HR system. One vendor and one data set, and often the simplest start. Check the module runs calibration and goals the way you need, and whether it sits in a higher plan.
  • Standalone performance platforms. Tools built around reviews, goals and calibration, connected to the HRIS you keep. More depth on the review cycle; check the HRIS integration carefully.
  • All-in-one people platforms. HR records, performance, engagement and sometimes pay in one suite. Fewer systems to manage; check you aren’t buying modules you won’t use.

To shortlist, start from your scorecard rather than a list of names. Map your stack with the stack-fit checker, then read the named comparisons: Lattice vs Culture Amp vs 15Five (with its own dated scorecard) and performance management software alternatives, sorted by why teams switch.

Where Revolut People fits

Revolut People can run reviews, goals and calibration alongside the HR system you keep. What its public documentation shows, against the scorecard:

When it isn’t the right fit: if you only need light check-ins without calibrated grades, structured calibration is more than you need. And if you want one vendor to replace your HRIS and performance tool together, this guide doesn’t assess that; the documentation cited here is about integrating with the HRIS you keep. Pricing isn’t listed here; use the pricing estimator. For a second opinion on your shortlist or scorecard, book a 15-minute review with Ash.

FAQs

What is the best performance management software in the UK?

There is no single best tool for every UK company. The right one is the tool that runs your own review process with the least workaround, passes your UK and Ireland checks (a documented process consistent with Acas guidance, access controls, data protection, HRIS and payroll integration) and gives you a clear written quote. Score your shortlist on the same eight criteria, then pilot the top two with two job families before you sign.

What features should performance management software have?

Goals that link to reviews; self, peer, manager and upward input; calibration that shows ratings by manager and records every change with a reason; a written record each employee can see; documented integrations with your HRIS and identity provider; role-based and regional permissions; and transparent pricing for your headcount.

What UK-specific checks matter (Acas, UK GDPR)?

Acas says employers should conduct regular performance reviews for employees, ideally at least once a year, and keep a written record that is shared with the employee. Check the tool supports that. For UK GDPR, and the EU GDPR in Ireland, check who can see ratings and feedback, retention settings, subject access exports and where data is stored and processed. Ask vendors about data location in writing.

How do I pilot a performance management tool before buying?

Pick two job families that work differently, write their scorecards and rating scale, and put the same people through your top two tools for one short cycle, including a calibration session. Score each tool straight after, ask managers how long it took, and agree with each vendor up front how a pilot works, what it costs and what happens to the data afterwards.

Is performance management software worth it for a small business?

Not always. A small team with a clear written process can run reviews in documents or spreadsheets. Software starts to pay off when consistency across managers, calibration and a reliable record in one place matter. Estimate what your current cycle costs first with the performance review cost calculator.

What does Revolut People cost?

This guide doesn’t list prices. Use the pricing estimator for an estimate for your headcount, and ask for a written quote that states any minimums, add-ons and implementation fees, as you would with any vendor.