This is a usable performance review template for CPOs, People leaders and managers. It follows the method in the Performance Management Playbook: three lenses (deliverables, skills and culture), yes or no scorecard statements, a five-level grade, evidence notes and calibration notes. It is the working version of the template outline in the performance management framework. New to the method? Start with the 5-step performance management framework and diagram. The detailed playbooks come from QuantumLight; Ash did not author them.

Where this fits: this template is the working document for steps 2 and 4 of the 5-step performance management framework (scorecards and the quarterly review). Next step: when every review is complete, run a calibration meeting to check the grades.

UK or Ireland? If you searched for a staff appraisal template, use the UK staff appraisal template (question bank, worked example, and a written record in line with Acas guidance). This page is the playbook’s scorecard template. For a new hire still in probation, start with the UK probation review template. If you also collect peer or upward input, start with the 360 feedback template, then bring themes — not a popularity score — into this scorecard.

How to use the template

  1. Pick two critical job families. Write their talent bar and scorecards first, run one cycle, then extend (the playbook’s own tip).
  2. Pre-fill the header (employee, role, seniority level, review period, reviewer) so every review is judged against the bar for that level.
  3. Managers answer yes or no to each statement and add a one-line evidence note. Same questions for everyone limits manager bias.
  4. Convert to a grade on the five-level scale, then send to calibration.
  5. Feed the result into the next 1:1 after leadership approves it.

The people, scores and notes below are illustrative examples written for this page. They are not real employee data or benchmarks.

Rating scale

The playbook converts the scorecard result into a numeric score and then a grade on a five-level scale. The thresholds are yours to set for your company. The example below shows the style of the criteria for deliverables. See employee performance rating scales explained for more on writing the levels.

GradeDeliverables: speedDeliverables: qualityDeliverables: complexity
PoorUsually delivers late and misses important deadlinesOutput quality is unacceptably lowOnly routine tasks done many times before
BasicUsually on time, rarely misses deadlinesAcceptable standard, sometimes needs several iterationsMix of standard and non-standard tasks
IntermediateAlways meets deadlines, often beats themHigh standard, typically one iterationMany non-standard tasks with few comparisons
AdvancedVery fast, habitually beats deadlinesAlways one iteration, exceptionally high standardHighly complex tasks with little precedent
ExceptionalIdentifies important targets, beats deadlines by huge marginsLinks any task to the business vision and designs the process to execute itExceptionally difficult work that needs radically new processes

The template

Copy the template into a spreadsheet or form tool, one copy per employee per review period. It has eight sections: Header, Goals, Deliverables scorecard, Skills scorecard, Culture scorecard, Calculated grade, Calibration notes and Outcome and next step.

The full template shows what to write in each section and who fills it in, followed by guidance for the goals and evidence sections, a filled-in worked example for a fictional Mid-level analyst and worked calibration notes. It is free with your work email.

Writing good evidence notes

The evidence note is what makes a yes or no answer credible in calibration. Each note should be one line and point to something another manager could check. Before the cycle, give managers the review-prep checklist for managers, and see how to prepare managers to use this template.

  • Name the work. “Led the pricing page rebuild, shipped two weeks early” is better than “delivered well this quarter”.
  • Say what changed as a result. A decision taken, a customer issue closed, a process another team now uses.
  • Cover the whole period. If every note is from the last month, ask what happened earlier; this limits recency bias (see the performance review bias guide).
  • Separate facts from judgement. Write what happened first, then the rating. It makes challenges in calibration easier to resolve. For longer comments organised by rating level, each with the evidence that justifies it, see the performance review examples. If you are running the year-end or mid-year cycle itself, use the year-end performance review run sheet and template.

Running the review conversation

The template is the record; the conversation is where it lands. A simple running order for a 30 to 45-minute meeting:

  1. Open with the outcome. Share the calibrated grade early so the person is not waiting for it.
  2. Walk through the evidence. Go section by section: deliverables, skills, culture. Invite the person to add anything you missed.
  3. Agree one or two growth areas. Pick the lowest-scoring areas that matter most for the next level, not every gap.
  4. Set the next checkpoint. Put a date in the diary to review progress in a 1:1, ideally within the next month.

Common mistakes with review templates

  • Changing the template mid-cycle. Everyone in a cycle should be assessed against the same version.
  • Free-text boxes with no prompts. They produce long, inconsistent answers. Specific statements with a yes or no and an evidence line are faster to fill in and easier to compare.
  • A different template for every team. Keep one structure and vary only the role-specific scorecard statements.
  • Skipping the outcome section. A review that does not end in an agreed next step is easily forgotten by the next cycle.

Redesigning your own form rather than copying this one? See what should be included in a performance review form: the nine sections, what to leave out and a four-week rebuild plan.

Related guides

Performance management framework: scorecards, talent bar and calibration · UK probation review: template and 2027 changes · 360 feedback template: questions by rater · performance review examples by rating level · year-end performance review: HR run sheet and template · how to run a performance calibration meeting · employee performance rating scales explained · performance management software buyer’s guide · What questions should a manager ask in a performance review? · Publish a talent bar by seniority · People Performance Playbook home

Free tools: estimate what your review cycle costs with the performance review cost calculator, or see if your HRIS is holding performance back with the HRIS switch checker.

Build the scorecard: get criteria with behavioural anchors for a role family and level from the review scorecard builder, edit them and save as a PDF.

FAQ

What should a performance review template include?

The playbook’s template has a header (employee, role, seniority level, review period, reviewer), a deliverables scorecard, a skills scorecard, a culture scorecard, a calculated grade, calibration notes, and an outcome and next step. This page adds a goals section and an evidence note for every answer.

How do I rate performance in the template?

Managers answer yes or no to scorecard statements about observable behaviour. The result becomes a numeric score and then a grade on a five-level scale: Poor, Basic, Intermediate, Advanced, Exceptional. You set the score thresholds for your company.

What goes in the calibration notes?

Any adjustment to a grade, the reason for it, and flags for missing evidence, generous grading or unexplained jumps. Senior leadership reviews and approves the final grades.

Are the worked examples real data?

No. The employee, goals and scores are illustrative and were written for this page. Only the method and criteria come from the Performance Management Playbook.

Can I get the full playbook?

Yes. The full Performance Management Playbook PDF is free with your name and work email via the form linked on this page. The guidance on this page is readable without a form; the full template, worked example and calibration notes are free with your work email.