A UK staff appraisal is the same conversation many teams call a performance review. Acas notes that performance reviews are “sometimes known as ‘appraisals’” (as checked 13 Nov 2026). This page is for line managers and HR managers in the UK and Ireland who searched for an appraisal template, not a “performance review” form.
Every section of the template is on this page, with a question bank and a worked example for a fictional role, so you can start without a form. If you want a Word file you can edit — and open in Google Docs — it is free with your work email, using the same form as the other Playbook downloads.
This sits alongside the playbook’s performance review template, which uses yes-or-no scorecards, a five-level grade and calibration notes. Use that when you want the scorecard method. Use this page when you want a UK appraisal form, in appraisal language, that still ties the write-up to evidence, a rating scale and calibration rather than ending at a signature.
This guide is for managers preparing appraisals in mid-market teams. It extends the performance management framework. Disclosure: Ash Taherian is Product Sales Executive at Revolut People, which sells performance management software. Treat product mentions as coming from an interested party.
Download the staff appraisal template
The Word file matches the sections below, and includes the question bank and the fictional worked example as appendices. After you download it, upload it to Google Drive and open it with Google Docs if you would rather edit it there. The same sections are also on this page, so you can copy them into a document of your own if you prefer to start in the browser.
This is not a substitute for Acas’s own appraisal form templates, which are free to download and include forms for appraisals against job objectives, manual workers, potential for promotion, self-appraisal, and a scheme review questionnaire (as checked 13 Nov 2026). Use this template when you want a single form that also prompts for evidence, wellbeing and development, and a link into ratings and calibration.
What a UK appraisal should cover
Acas’s performance-management guidance (last updated 23 June 2026; checked 13 Nov 2026) says a performance review is a chance to discuss someone’s work, including:
- what they are doing well
- any areas for improvement
- whether they need more support or training
- their career and any development objectives
It also says it is important to keep a written record of what is discussed, and that this should be shared with the employee afterwards. Objectives should be fair and reflect the employee’s usual tasks and workload. Acas recommends they are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound — also known as SMART objectives. In Acas’s own example, a manager and employee agree a measurable change, check it is achievable and relevant, discuss progress in regular check-ins, and arrange a meeting to review it in three months.
This is guidance, not legal advice. For the official wording, read Acas on reviews and appraisals. Acas’s “at least once a year” point applies to people with the legal status of employee. The same page notes that someone is not likely to be an employee if they are an agency worker, a casual worker or on a zero-hours contract, and that employers might still choose to hold reviews for workers (as checked 13 Nov 2026). If you are unsure about status, use official guidance or your own HR or legal advice — this page cannot settle that.
| Acas point | Where it sits in this template |
|---|---|
| What is going well | Objectives and results, and the strengths side of skills and behaviours, each with evidence. |
| Areas for improvement | Objectives that slipped, difficulties, and development needs, written as evidence rather than labels. |
| Support or training | Support, wellbeing and development, plus any help agreed for the next period. |
| Career and development objectives | Support, wellbeing and development, and objectives for the next period. |
| SMART objectives | Objectives and results (looking back) and objectives for the next period (looking forward), with a measure and a review point. |
| Written record, shared afterwards | Employee comments and sign-off: the record is shared, not only signed. |
Between formal appraisals, Acas says managers should still talk to employees informally about their performance, for example through regular feedback, coaching and regular check-ins, sometimes known as one-to-ones. For an agenda and questions, see the one-to-one meeting template. The review-prep checklist is the manager’s preparation list for the formal conversation.
How to use this template
You can work from the sections on this page or from the Word file. A simple way to run one appraisal is:
- Share the questions in advance. Send the employee the self-appraisal questions, last period’s objectives, and a date for the meeting, so both of you can gather evidence from the whole period. The review-prep checklist is the manager’s preparation list.
- Ask the employee to complete a self-appraisal first. Acas provides a separate self-appraisal form if you want a stand-alone sheet (as checked 13 Nov 2026). The question bank below can also be used as the self-appraisal.
- Fill in the template from the evidence, then meet. Write the record so another manager could check it. Leave space for the employee’s comments, including any disagreement, and share the written record afterwards.
- Set two or three SMART objectives for the next period, with a measure and a review point, and put the informal check-ins in the diary.
- Take the draft grade to calibration once you have converted the evidence onto your published rating scale. The write-up should not end at a signature.
The template, section by section
Copy the sections into a document, one copy per person per review period. Keep the same structure for every team; change only the role-specific objectives and behaviour statements.
| Section | What to record | Who fills it in |
|---|---|---|
| Review details | Name, job title, team, reviewer, review period, meeting date, and whether this is an annual, mid-year or other appraisal. | Manager, before the meeting. |
| Objectives and results | Last period’s objectives, the result, the evidence, and what helped or got in the way. Note any objective that changed mid-period. | Manager, with the employee’s self-appraisal in view. |
| Skills and behaviours | How the work was done, with observable examples, against your behaviours or the playbook’s skills and culture statements. | Manager, after reading the self-appraisal. |
| Evidence | A checkable note for each judgement: a project, a date, a customer outcome, or a 1:1 note. | Manager; the employee can add examples too. |
| Support, wellbeing and development | Support or training that would help, whether the workload is sustainable, and what the person wants to develop. | Discussed together; the manager writes the record. |
| Objectives for the next period | Two or three SMART objectives, with a measure and a review point. | Agreed together. |
| Employee comments and sign-off | The employee’s own comments, including any disagreement, and confirmation that the written record was shared, with names and dates. | Employee comments; both record that it was shared. |
Review details
Pre-fill the employee’s name, job title, team, reviewer, review period, the date of the meeting, and whether this is an annual, mid-year or other appraisal. Do this before the meeting so the conversation is about the period, not the form.
Objectives and results
List last period’s objectives. For each one, record the result, the evidence, and a short comment on what helped or got in the way. If an objective changed mid-period, say so. A blank where the work moved is harder to defend later than a short note that the objective was replaced, and why.
Skills and behaviours
Record how the person did the work, not only what they delivered. Use your organisation’s behaviours, or the skills and culture statements in the performance review template and the rating scale. Stick to observable examples another manager could recognise.
Evidence
Every judgement should point to something another manager could check: a project, a date, a customer outcome, a 1:1 note. That is what makes the write-up usable in calibration. Thin evidence is one of the three checks in the playbook’s calibration meeting.
Support, wellbeing and development
Ask what support or training would help, whether the workload is sustainable, and what the person wants to develop. Acas lists support, training, career and development objectives as part of the review (as checked 13 Nov 2026). This is a discussion, not a diagnosis. If a wellbeing concern needs occupational health or another formal route, follow your organisation’s policy.
Objectives for the next period
Agree two or three objectives, not a long list. Write them as SMART objectives, with a measure and a review point. Acas’s example agrees a measurable change, checks it is achievable and relevant, and sets a meeting to review it in three months, with progress discussed in regular check-ins (as checked 13 Nov 2026).
Employee comments and sign-off
Leave space for the employee’s own comments, including any disagreement. Then record that the written record was shared with them, with names and dates for the employee and the manager. A signature is not the point of the form; the shared record is, which is what Acas advises.
Appraisal questions
A short bank, by theme, for the manager and for self-appraisal. Share the questions in advance so both of you can bring evidence from the whole period, not only the last few weeks. For a longer running order for the conversation itself, see what questions a manager should ask in a performance review.
| Theme | Manager questions | Self-appraisal questions |
|---|---|---|
| Objectives and results | Which of last period’s objectives were met, partly met or missed, and what evidence shows that? If an objective changed, what replaced it? | Which objectives are you most satisfied with, and where did the work go differently than planned? |
| Strengths, difficulties and evidence | What should we recognise, and where did the work get stuck? What would another manager be able to check? | What are you proud of in this period, and what was harder than you expected? Please give an example for each. |
| Role clarity | Is the role still clear? Has the work drifted from the job as it was set at the start of the period? | Is anything in the role unclear, or taking time that does not belong there? |
| Workload, wellbeing and support | Is the workload sustainable? What support, time or training would have helped, or would help next? | What support would help you do the job well, and is there anything about workload or wellbeing I should know? |
| Development | What should we develop in the next period, and how will we know it is happening? | What do you want to get better at, and what support would make that realistic? |
| Next period’s objectives | What two or three SMART objectives should we set, and when will we review them? | What should your objectives be next, and how should we measure them? |
Worked example
The person, employer, objectives, figures and comments below are a fictional example written for this page. They are not real employee data or a benchmark.
Sam Ellis is a mid-level customer support team leader at a fictional mid-market UK company. The review period is 1 May 2025 to 30 April 2026. The reviewer is Sam’s line manager. The comments use the playbook’s five-level scale, where Intermediate is a solid rating.
| Section | Fictional example |
|---|---|
| Review details | Sam Ellis, customer support team leader. Reviewer: line manager. Period: 1 May 2025 to 30 April 2026. Annual appraisal, meeting held 12 May 2026. |
| Objectives and results | 1. Cut the team’s average first-response time on the priority inbox from two working days to one. Met: the team hit one working day in January 2026 and held it through April, based on the weekly inbox report. 2. Train two new starters so the cover rota no longer depends on one person. Met: both starters completed the desk book and ran a solo shift from March. 3. Draft a short quality-check sampling method. Partly met: a draft exists, but sampling only started in April, so there is not yet a full quarter of data. |
| Skills and behaviours | Coaching is visible in the two starter plans and in Friday huddle notes. Planning still slips when two projects overlap — the quality-check work landed late because inbox cover was prioritised, without an earlier flag in the Monday 1:1. |
| Evidence | Weekly inbox report (May 2025–April 2026); starter training records; huddle notes; April sampling log. No evidence is taken from outside this review period. |
| Support, wellbeing and development | Sam asked for a clearer rule on when quality-check work can slip behind inbox cover. Workload was heavy in November and December; that is recorded, and the next period should not add a third major project without a capacity check. Development focus: planning across overlapping work, and coaching the two starters beyond onboarding. |
| Objectives for the next period | 1. Keep first-response time at one working day on the priority inbox, reviewed monthly. 2. Run the quality-check sample every week and share a short trend note in the last 1:1 of each month. 3. Put a weekly capacity check on the team meeting agenda, and flag clashes in the Monday 1:1 rather than absorbing extra work. Review all three at a mid-period meeting in three months, with progress in regular check-ins. |
| Employee comments and sign-off | Sam agreed the write-up, added that the December peak felt harder than the report shows, and asked that the mid-period review also look at cover during peaks. The written record was shared on 12 May 2026. |
Appraisal comments examples
Short, illustrative comments you can adapt. They are not real employee data. Keep your own comments specific, dated and tied to evidence, and avoid labels without examples. A longer set of comments and self-evaluation examples, organised by rating level and with the evidence that justifies each one, is in the performance review examples.
| Type | Example comment |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Sam reduced the team’s average first-response time on the priority inbox from two working days to one, and trained two new starters so the cover rota no longer depends on one person. |
| Development | Planning still slips when two projects overlap. Before the next period, we agreed Sam will put a weekly capacity check in the team meeting and flag clashes in the Monday 1:1, rather than absorbing the extra work. |
| Overall | On the evidence from this period, Sam met the two core objectives and is working at Intermediate on the five-level scale for this level. The next period should stretch planning and coaching, not add a longer task list. |
After the appraisal: ratings and calibration
The write-up is not finished at sign-off. Convert the evidence into a grade on a published rating scale — the playbook uses a five-level scale from Poor to Exceptional, and Intermediate is a solid rating, not a dumping ground. Then take draft grades to performance calibration so people doing similar work at the same level are held to the same standard. The meeting itself is in how to run a performance calibration meeting.
If you are preparing the whole cycle rather than one form, use the review-cycle checklist and the performance management framework. For a wider UK and Ireland picture of how often managers talk about performance, see the 2026 benchmarks. For how often to review, Acas’s “at least once a year” guidance is discussed in the FAQ below and in how often performance reviews should be conducted.
Related guides
Performance review template with worked examples · 360 feedback template: questions by rater · performance review examples by rating level · year-end performance review: HR run sheet and template · PIP template for UK managers · performance management framework · employee performance rating scales explained · performance calibration · 9-box grid: how it works, a free template, and when to replace it · how to run a performance calibration meeting · review-prep checklist · review-cycle checklist · what questions a manager should ask in a performance review · free tools · People Performance Playbook home
Free tools: estimate what your review cycle costs with the performance review cost calculator, or get a dated view of published vendor prices with the pricing estimator.
FAQ
What should a staff appraisal template include?
A UK staff appraisal template should record the review period and role, progress against last period’s objectives with evidence, strengths and difficulties, skills and behaviours, support and development needs, two or three objectives for the next period with how they’ll be measured, and the employee’s own comments. Acas advises keeping a written record of what was discussed and sharing it with the employee (as checked 13 Nov 2026).
What questions should I ask in an appraisal?
Cover achievements against last period’s objectives, strengths and difficulties with evidence, role clarity, workload, wellbeing and support, development, and two or three SMART objectives for the next period. This page has a question bank for the manager and for self-appraisal. Share the questions in advance so both of you can bring evidence.
Is an appraisal the same as a performance review?
Yes. In the UK, “appraisal” and “performance review” usually mean the same conversation. Acas notes that performance reviews are sometimes known as appraisals (as checked 13 Nov 2026).
How often should appraisals happen in the UK?
Acas says employers should conduct regular performance reviews for anyone with the legal status of employee, and that it is a good idea to do them at least once a year (as checked 13 Nov 2026). That is official guidance, not a statement that a yearly appraisal is a legal requirement, and this page is not legal advice. The playbook itself uses a quarterly review cycle. Between formal appraisals, Acas still advises informal feedback, coaching and regular check-ins.
Can I use this instead of the performance review template?
Yes, if you want a UK appraisal form in appraisal language. Use the performance review template when you want the playbook’s yes-or-no scorecards, five-level grade and calibration notes in one working document. The two pages are meant to sit together, not to compete.
Are the worked example and comments real?
No. The person, objectives, figures and comments were written for this page as a fictional example. Only the method and the Acas points are from published sources.